
Now there are three women of a certain age!
A visit from my brother brought with it a longing for family once again.
He being a 'self made man' has no time for apologys, birthdates, anniversaries or such nonsense and is often heard saying;
"Don't let anyone do anything for nothing".
Charity is indeed something to be stepped into only with very specific instructions.
Charity for the those who live in your neighbourhood, but not overseas.
Charity for those who look like you.
Charity under very special hard looked considerations.
Charity beginning at home really starts and ends with IMMEDIATE family. ie children
These are his guidelines.
So it is with great reluctance as once again we set out to make guests comfortable, welcome, warm and well fed, we find ourselves being in the middle of a bind.
With food proffered ( left overs) and two bottles of wine we feel we are well satisfied at our hospitality being accepted.
BUT as they left and cleaning up the next day money was found secreted under the computer's mouse.
I was reminded, by nothing in particular, of the saying of 'cold as charity'.
This does nothing for either participant.
The giver is made to feel that their offering is worthless and cruel ( so don't do it) and the receiver is made to feel that that which they need so badly as to accept gratis, is disgusting and shameful.
Where did the saying originate?
It feels like Dickens, and somewhere in Britain where the middle classes were struggling with the idea of equality of the masses. This has never concerned the upper classes as it is as foreign as a different language.
The upper classes never had manners, but what was imagined by the middle classes was set by them not by their betters at all (all thus according to HWMBO).
The lower classes were free of the need for manners, but did have a certain honour system, similar to that 'amongst thieves'. Those whose needs were so great could not stand on ceremony.
So the middle classes were the ones to set up the rules of etiquette, rules of law and were the ones to lead the masses into revolution.
And so back to the realisation of cold charity.
What was that 'rule' that 'maxim' suppose to offer?
So with a dry taste in my mouth and after much quiet discussion with HWMBO I accepted the gift , without fuss..a simple thank you.
But it tastes awful and is not made more palatable because of the attitude of the person, my brother, who gave it.
There is a way to receive gifts and a way to give gifts. He, poor man, can do neither well.
So I sit here hoping that he feels a little lighter in heart feeling that he gave to his poor-cousin-sister and she received without fuss or bother.
Ahh the freedom money must allow the wealthy...
Freedom of twisted logic, freedom from churned accepting of charity.
And so my lessons continue.
3 comments:
Your posting reminded me of the times Maryann's parents would visit. They would invariably leave money somewhere in the house. Both of us were quite amused by the gesture. We didn't "need" the money. In fact, we used to find it and figure out some way to return it without their knowing. It was a very amusing game.
I was quite touched by your story. Your brother's idea of charity brings sadness to me. I believe I understand his perspective, I don't completely agree with it.
It would appear that he has not received much assistance during his life. Perhaps I am wrong about this. However, I believe you receive what you give. Hence my supposition posited above.
Please ask HWMBO what his perspective is about keeping the hidden "gift"? My thought is to be as gracious as you can when accepting gifts. It will put an entirely different slant on the exchange. Otherwise, you may just be agreeing with the attitude of the giver. Just some thoughts.
Maryann and I used to have a discussion about receiving gifts from others. She was acculturated to say no thank you. My viewpoint revolved around the entire exchange. For a person to give there must be a person willing to receive. It is a two way street.
Thanks once again for posting a very interesting situation. You don't have to stoop to the other person's view of the world. Rejoice that you were provided the gift. Don't you just know it will probably make him wonder what you have been smoking?
And, continue to...
serve with integrity, care about those you serve, and share the love in your heart.
My best to you all.
Thank you for your thoughts on this and for sharing them with me.
Now THAT is a gift I can accept happily!!
You are most welcome!!!
Post a Comment