In
Law, Legislation and Liberty , Friedrich Hayek wrote:
“The effective limitation of power is the most important problem of social order.
Government is indispensable for the formulation of such an order only to protect
against coercion and violence from others. But as soon as, to achieve this,
Government successfully claims the monopoly of coercion and violence,
it becomes the chief threat to individual freedom.”
In the epilogue to his epic
A History of Australia, Manning Clark wrote:
“This generation has a chance to be wiser than previous generations.
They can make their own history. With the end of the domination by
the straiteners, the enlargers of life now have their chance. … It is the
task of the historian and the mythmaker to tell the story of how the
world came to be as it is. It is the task of the prophet to tell the story of
what might be. The historian presents the choice: history is a book of
wisdom for those making that choice.”
Australians have a strong instinct for human rights.
Public and political rhetoric tends to favour human rights.
Although Australia does not have a written Bill of Rights,
we have a shared sense that some ideals are basic to our society.
Most of the basic elements of a constitutional democracy are
found in our Constitution, but others are taken for granted:
we tacitly accept them as basic and inalienable.
The American formulation “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness”
is not only familiar to us from TV dramas; it is a pretty fair reflection
of our own assumptions. For most of us, the assumption remains untested.
The starting point in an argument about a Bill of Rights is that,
within the scope of its legislative competence, Parliament’s power is
unlimited. The classic example of this is that, if Parliament has power
to make laws with respect to children, it could validly pass a law which
required all blue-eyed babies to be killed at birth. The law, although
terrible, would be valid. One response to this is that a democratic system allows that government to be thrown out at the next election.
This is not much comfort for the blue-eyed babies born in the meantime.
And even this democratic correction may not be enough:
if blue-eyed people are an unpopular minority, the majority
may prefer to return the government to power.
The Nuremberg laws of Germany in the 1930s were horrifying,
but were constitutionally valid laws which attracted the support of many Germans.
Here is a man of the court system who is thinking, considering and morally attuned.
Thank heavens for Julian in our poverty stricken justice system.